Our Pizza

Why travel several miles when you take a short drive to the best pizza place in town. We offer a wide variety of selection from our Calzones to Pizza Wraps and even our popular Sicilian pizza. So if you craving the best pizza just in the area, stop in and experience the taste. 

We pride ourselves in using the finest cheese and the best tomatoes for that fresh taste that our customers have come to expect. All our vegetables are fresh, not in a can and our dough is made daily on our premises.

Regular Brick Oven Pizza



Meatballs ◆ Pepperoni ◆ Fresh Tomatoes 
◆ Mushrooms ◆ Eggplant ◆ Onions ◆ Black pizza123Olives ◆ Jalapenos ◆ Salami ◆ Peppers ◆ Fresh Garlic ◆ Sausage


Deluxe Topping:

Ham 1.25 Sicilian | 2.00 Extra


Ind 10"
Sm 14"
Lg 18"

 Gluten Free Pizza Available - 12" Pie - 10.95

Full Menu

p44Our complete menu includes appetizers, soups, salads amd dinner entrees, and even a kids menu. Our food is made fresh daily, and you won't be dissapointed. If it's pizza you like, we offer a wide variety of toppings, and have specialty brick oven pizzas too. Come and try our Margherita pie or maybe our Chicken Cacciatore pizza.

About Goodfellas

p22Family run business, we opened in 1996. Serving the residents of Dutchess County and Red Oaks Mill for over 16 years!!! We are passionate about good Italian food.  We take pride in the quality of our meals, and always aim to please.  With our dough and other ingredients prepared fresh daily, we are able to provide a fantastic meal every time. 

Dine In / Take Out

p1123Come in, sit down, and relax with family and friends. Goodfellas has a full dining area for your convenience. Whether it's traditional pizza you're looking for, or perhaps a full dinner menu with hot appetizers, soup, salad and a dinner entree, Goodfellas is your choice for the best food in town.


  Open Close
Sunday 12:00pm 9:00pm
Monday 11:00am 10:00pm
Tuesday 11:00am 10:00pm
Wednesday 11:00am 10:00pm
Thursday 11:00am 10:00pm
Friday 11:00am 10:00pm
Saturday 11:00am 10:00pm

Call Us



Red Oaks Mill Plaza

47 Vassar Road

Poughkeepsie, NY 12603

About Us

Goodfellas Pizzaria & Restaurant is located in Red Oaks Mill and provides dine-in/take-out Pizza and Italian Dinners. From soup to salad, or appetizers to dinner entrees, Goodfellas will amaze you with their delicious, freshly made italian cuisine. Gluten free selections available.

Find Us